Social Media Privacy Vulnerabilities
I’ve been thinking for a long time about what the topic of my next blog post would be.
As most of you know, I work full time at the University of Guelph, and I support my fiancé with his photography business as a photographer, and I dabble in freelance design and jewellery design.
With so many different creative outlets, I never get to really post or talk about topics I really love, like helping people.
For the longest time, I’ve sat back and observed how we the mass, have rocketed into social media, and I don’t feel we actually realize what information is really out there about ourselves. I’m not talking about the social media versed, or the computer programmer. I’m talking about the average users, my mom, my sisters, my cousins, my aunts and my friends.
I feel people in general don’t realize exactly how the information you are sharing on these social media sites, like facebook and twitter, is being read, stored and indexed.
We know that these sites are used for the greater good like forming online communities reaching together to support crisis, charities, lost children, women and just general information sharing. What about the other side of the information sharing?
I’m going to create scenarios for you, using instances to explain my points, all names are made up.
A young women (I will call her “Air”) in her 20’s, living alone, working in a city, let’s say Toronto, Ontario. Air works as an administrator for a large company downtown Toronto. She lives outside of the Toronto core, and takes the subway into work every day. She takes the same train, same times, every day. She has a close group of girl friends she regularly goes out with. She works out at a gym near her house every other day. All of which she posts about on her facebook, and occasionally will twitter about. She frequently twitters about her favourite bands, she just loves the local music scene and loves posting reviews about what she’s attending next.
Air, has an iphone, she takes it everywhere. It keeps her connected to her friends via texting, online friends via Facebook and family when they call her.
Air, is searchable, vulnerable and stockable and she doesn’t even realize it.
Here is a scenario for you to put it all into perspective:
Air, posts on her facebook wall, “I’m so tired, leaving for work soon, need coffee first”, and twitters a picture of her coffee “Great band last night, late night, result this big coffee #starbucksaveshangover”.
She gets ready same time as yesterday and the day before, coffee in hand, walks down the dark stairs to the subway….
Air, is vulnerable, and she doesn’t even realize it.
Some people may be saying, but my facebook is private and only my friends can see what I post! Well, some time ago, facebook and twitter signed a deal with google exchanging our information for money. The privacy settings on facebook changed, and now instead of everything being defaulted to private, it is default to ‘everyone’ (my boss, we talk about this a lot, he says go to delicious.com and you can search for ‘facebook, twitter, google deal’) this means, not just your friends or networks can see your information, but google too.
Air has 200 facebook friends, out of those 200, 20 of them are her closest friends. They post comments on each other’s wall about meeting up, great times they have, tag each other in pictures, some of her friends moving, bands they see, etc. 10 of those 20 good friends’ privacy settings are set to ‘everyone’. This means that if I search Air’s facebook profile that is locked, I can still see her friends list. I can click on ‘view all’; I can click on each link and look for friends that have an ‘open’ wall. I can then see all the information I want to about Air’s friend’s wall. To which Air has posted “Hi Wind, see you tonight, 8pm at the local bar, I’m totally wearing that red shirt you gave me for Christmas”.
Air is vulnerable, and she doesn’t even realize it.
Another scenario:
Air is heading to the local pub, she twitters “just heading out to see bandname at local pub #pubname #bandname”. Air is at the pub now, she’s with Wind (her friend from facebook), She twitters “band is awesome, even from the back of the room #pubname”. Wind posts on twitter “sitting with Air she’s wearing the red shirt I gave her, looks awesome#bandname#pubname”.
Fire, a man at that pub, he’s also following the band’s twitter feed, afterall he is their biggest fan. He follows their twitter posts and “#” searches. He see’s Air’s post and Wind’s post, he looks for a red shirt at the back of the bar, and see’s her sitting there with her friend. He takes her picture with his iphone because he thinks she’s so pretty, and she’s got good taste, she likes the band he loves.
He searches for her name on his iphone through google, and pulls up a locked facebook account profile page that looks like the picture he just took, to which it shows him, her basic information. He knows she’s single, he knows she lives in Toronto, he knows where she works (because she didn’t change her information privacy settings), he does a quick look through her friends list and finds a picture of Wind, Wind’s facebook profile is completely open.
He does a quick scan of Wind’s wall, he now know’s Air goes to starbucks every morning, he knows from one of her posts “Hey Wind, stuck at the “homelocationtermnial” going to be late for work and everything, something wrong with the subway car” where she goes every morning and the approximate area that she lives in.
Fire gets up and walks over to Air, introduces himself and starts a lovely conversation with her and Wind about the band, Toronto and how cute she is. They exchange numbers, Air is flattered that a guy so cute as Fire, seemed so nice!
Fire, takes Air’s phone number and does a canada411.ca reverse phone number lookup, and finds her exact address. He can then use google map’s street view, and he finds her street, complete with a photograph of her home and car in the driveway. He also finds the nearest starbucks, and subway station.
The next morning, Air finds herself leaving the starbucks, and somehow bumps right into Fire, thinking it’s a complete co-incidence. They have a short conversation and she leaves towards the subway.
Air is so vulnerable, and she doesn’t even realize it.
I’ve noticed that women in general, for some reason we divulge a lot of information to our friends online, we don’t realize the vulnerability points that we create for ourselves.
We don’t realize how searchable we are. We haven’t caught up to the fact that our information, our online social outlets aren’t that private. I’m going to repeat that. We havn’t caught up to the fact that our information, our online social outlets aren’t that private. We don’t realize that with even such little information, we can be extremely vulnerable.
I’m not saying don’t use social media, I’m saying we need to be smarter.
My Advice:
If you are using facebook, know what your friends’ privacy settings are, don’t assume everyone is private.
Try logging off of facebook, and searching for yourself. Search for your friends and see if you can find out your information like a stranger could. Then you’ll know how locked down your privacy settings are, and what your friends settings are.
Don’t post information about yourself and where you are going, your information is archived, searchable and index-able.
Never post information about what you are wearing.
Never give strangers your phone number, or email address, specially the guy you just met in the pub.
Sure he’s cute; sure he’s into you right now. How do you know he didn’t just ‘google/twitter/facebook you?’ Your phone number is searchable, and with Google’s new street view, your home is connected to your phone number, photos and all. Complete with a ‘get directions to here ‘ button. If you get talking to someone at a pub/bar, or other place like that, suggest meeting up again at a more public place like a mall courtyard for a coffee, not in the same neighbourhood that you live in either. Take your friend with you.
When you are at an event, and you feel the need to twitter about it, don’t post information about where you are in that room, place etc.
Don’t ever post information about specific places you will be, at specific times.
Change your routine, if you do the same things every day, why not change it up a little? take a later train, walk a different route, be un predictable.
I’ll be posting more often now, and hopefully I’ll go more into details and specifics about online privacy to help people.
Stay safe, be smarter.


13 Comments
Catherine
February 4, 2010Great points Amanda! I am glad you posted this, and I hope people take it seriously, even myself, I know I don’t have my info locked down properly. I guess it’s scary to think that there are actually people who would misuse this sort of Social Networking will ill intention.
Mary
February 4, 2010Amanda,
You’ve provided lots of good information that should make us all think more carefully about what we say on Facebook, Twitter and even in email. I think I’ll share some of your thoughts with my own friends.
Carolyn
February 4, 2010This article should be printed and passed out to all people using social networking! and i think schools should also hand out this information!.. We are too trusting and believe we are safe..predators are lurking. This is one of the best article’s i have read it explains so much!
Avril
February 4, 2010Awesome post! It’s so funny that you posted about this topic – I was just thinking the other day that I hate how now, anybody can search for your picture on Facebook – they used to have settings so that only your friends could interact with you and view your profile picture, but they changed that recently so that the most restrictive setting is “Friends of friends can add and contact me”.
Also, waaaay too many people leave their phone numbers and othere sensitive information on people’s walls, instead of just sending them a private message. It always makes me cringe to see that.
Amanda
February 4, 2010Yes, Avril, I agree. I will be doing more posts in the future, one of which will be on different privacy settings of facebook’s, how they are expolited and what they really mean. Thank you everyone for your comments, pass the post around and continue to comment! Stay safe, be Smarter.
Nikki
February 4, 2010Thank you for posting this. You’ve brought up a subject that is so important, but doesn’t seem to get the attention it deserves. You’ve written it in a way that makes it easily understood for teenagers, and people who may not be familiar with how the internet works. Thanks again.
joanne
February 4, 2010Didn’t even finish reading the whole story….it brought tears to my eyes. Going to send this to everyone I know. So scary.
Jennifer
February 5, 2010Great post!
Fadi
February 5, 2010Thanks Amanda, you do have good points. However, I have set my private options on fb and I have googled my name many times. I have also googled it after I read your article. The only links I have seen is places where I have chosen to be visible (Classmates, twitter and linkedIN) not facebook. You can disable the option on fb that makes you searchable on google or other search engine website. Not too sure about twitter. If you need help setting this up please let me know.
Amanda
February 5, 2010Hi Fadi,
Thank you for your comment, Yes i am well aware of how the google settings/ facebook settings work, my post was more geared towards people that don’t really realize it.
I can take your name, because I have a facebook account and search for it internally. I can use your email, or phone number to find you. There are other ways that people will and can use.
Take for instance facebook/google face regognition, and google now indexing our images, how hard is it going to be in the future, for people like ‘fire’ to find ‘air’ after snapping a photo of her with his iphone?
With groups like this working hard everyday to make information more accessible http://groups.google.com/group/fr4fb/?pli=1 it makes the stalker factor that much more scary. This article on Google Goggles http://thejakartaglobe.com/home/new-google-smartphone-application-with-face-recognition-sparks-privacy-concerns/348030 or this article, scroll down to the paragraph on cyberlink, http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2358831,00.asp makes me very weiry of our willingness to run full tilt into the fire.
I’m going to be posting more articles, talking more in depth about these topics, thank you Fadi for your comment, I really appreciate it.
An important post on privacy « Tangential Thoughts
February 16, 2010[...] than people I know personally, but I prefer to err on the side of caution. Especially in light of this post I read recently. While it talks about Facebook, blogs are still a form of social media and thus I [...]
Maeve
March 16, 2010I found your points very interesting….As a 14 year old who does use facebook (although i haven’t been twittering yet) i found it interesting to find a small negativity of facebook.thx
Mindie
June 11, 2010Amanda, thanks so much for this great information, and told in such a compelling way. My daughter is 13 and needs to read this. You may very well have saved lives by writing this blog post!